Should I trade David Ortiz and Tim Hudson for Justin Verlander and Grady Sizemore?

There's a lot to value here. Grady might return to his All-Star form and I think he will as long as he avoids long term injuries and so forth. I say go for it and be patient with Grady. It might take a while for him to go back to his All Star form. In fact, I think he will after the All Star break.